平和
和平
평화
ASIA
04 November 2026
Australia’s proud history?

Australia’s proud history?

There is much for Australia to feel proud about in its modern history, writes former prime minister, Tony Abbott, in a new book of Australian history, here reviewed by John West.

One important current in modern Australian historiography is the "black armband" view of Australian history. This focuses on the mistreatment, dispossession, and violence committed against Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.

Proponents of this view are opposed to celebrating Australia Day and wish to label it “invasion day”. Some are even reluctant to see anything much of worth in the British settlement of Australia. Against that, some aboriginal and other commentators argue that Australia was bound to be colonised by one of the world’s imperial powers, and the British were perhaps the most benign of them.

Tony Abbott and Australian History

In a remarkable development for Australia, former Prime Minister Tony Abbott decided to write a history of Australia that seeks to restore balance in the subject by arguing that Australians have far more to be proud of than ashamed of in their history (“Australia: A History: From convict colony to great democracy”). Based on the book, Sky News has produced a documentary of the same name, which can be seen freely online (see link in the references below).

Abbott argues that history matters because if you don't know where your country has been, it's very hard to understand where it is and it's almost impossible to create the best possible future. He sees three pillars upon which modern Australia rests – namely the indigenous heritage, the British foundation, and the immigrant character. But he laments the decline of the study of history in Australia. We don’t know our history or ourselves!

Settlement

The modern settlement of Australia was undertaken by British convicts, soldiers and administrators. British convicts were previously sent to America. But following its independence, England needed a new destination and that became Australia.

Abbott argues that convict settlement of Australia was perhaps the world’s greatest example of prisoner rehabilitation. He discusses the case of George Edwards Peacock, a solicitor in London, who was sentenced to death for forgery. This sentence was commuted to transportation to Australia for life.

Peacock became the 19th century version of a meteorologist at Sydney’s Southhead weather station. The weather records we have for Sydney from the late 1830s to the early 1850s are essentially the work of Peacock. In reality, transportation to Australia gave Peacock a second chance in life, beyond his wildest dreams.

I have a similar story in my own family, the case of my convict ancestor George Withers. He was a labourer, born on 12th October 1802, who was convicted of larceny at the Berkshire Court of Quarter Sessions. George received a sentence of 7 years and was transported by ship on the Guildford, departing England on 22 August 1823 and arriving in New South Wales 15 March 1824 with 160 passengers. George was lucky because the Guildford was lost at sea near Singapore in 1831, losing all aboard.

Ancestor George was also lucky because he met and married fellow prisoner, Susannah Lloyd, a farm servant. After several years, George and Susannah were set free and raised a family. George lived a long life for the time, dying at the age of 75. For her part, Susannah was convicted of theft at the Lancaster Quarter Session, and received a sentence term of 14 years. She was transported to New South Wales on the Harmony, departing 12th May 1827 and arriving 27th Sep 1827 with 80 passengers.

In sum, from the arrival of the first fleet of settlers in 1788, Australia has been a place where people have been able to come from all over the world and built a better life for themselves and their children. Abbott views the story of convict Australia as essentially a redemption story. That is the story of the majority of the 160,000 or so who came to Australia as convicts. Less than 10 percent of the convicts ended up going to the punishment centers like Port Arthur, Norfolk Island, Port Macquarie and Morton Bay.

Multiethnic Australia

There is much more to the European settlement of Australia than British convicts and their military and administrative companions. On the first fleet, there were Jews and black people. By the end of the 1850s there were something like 50,000 Chinese gold seekers taking part in the “gold rush”. That represents some 5 percent of the settler population of scarcely a million.

Many of the Chinese ultimately ultimately returned home, but many also stayed. For example, Trooper Yin Gan was one of the notable Chinese-Australian Anzacs who volunteered for service and was among the first Allied troops to land under heavy enemy fire at Anzac Cove on the Gallipoli Peninsula on April 25, 1915, during World War I.

Jews have also made a major contribution to Australia. John Monash was of German Jewish extraction. When he was put in charge of almost all of the Australians in France in World War 1, he immediately set about to win a local victory at Le Hamel, helping the Allies win the war. Sir Isaac Alfred Isaacs was an Australian lawyer, politician, and judge who served as the ninth governor-general of Australia.

Sir Zelman Cowen. Australian legal scholar and university administrator who served as the 19th governor-general of Australia. Abbott believes that no group of people have been as successful as Jewish Australians at both maintaining their own solidarity and sense of community, and at the same time making a marvelous contribution to wider Australia.

In discussing Australia’s multi-ethnic society, Abbott skates over tensions between the British Protestant large majority and Irish Catholic settlers who made up 20-25 percent of the population. This issue was very much alive in my youth. My Catholic mother spoke to me at length about being the victim of criticism and discrimination at the hands of my father’s British Protestant mother.

And in the Protestant-dominated government schools I attended, I always felt personally embarrassed to be a Catholic. Fortunately, these Protestant/Catholic divisions have waned, but they have been replaced by anti-Muslim and anti-Asian sentiments.

Postwar immigration

Abbott writes that post World War II immigration has been so much a part of modern Australia's success. Over 4.2 million migrants arrived between 1945 and 1985, including from countries like Italy, Greece, Germany, the Netherlands, and Malta, fundamentally altering Australian culture, cuisine, cities, and workplaces. It was expected that “new Australians” would integrate from day one and assimilate. If not entirely themselves, certainly their children would assimilate into the wider Australian community.

This phase of Australian immigration is now looked back upon fondly by writers like Abbott. But growing up as I did during the 1950s and 60s, I saw how immigrants from Mediterranean countries were identified by Anglo-Celts like me as being “different” and often called “wogs”. They were often mocked for their differences, like for their parents who didn’t speak English or their luncheon boxes full of smelly foods.

Australia's Greek and Italian immigrants in particular have achieved high levels of economic, social, and cultural integration, moving from post-WWII manual laborers into well-established pillars of modern Australian society. But Greek-Australian friends of my generation still felt under pressure from their parents to marry inside their ethnic group. In general however they do not transmit that expectation to their own children.

In sum, the process of immigrants’ economic, social, and cultural integration takes time and usually more than one generation.

Future of multiculturalism

Despite the undeniable success of Australia’s migration history, Abbott ponders whether we can continue to flourish as a multicultural society? There is currently a local debate about the number of immigrants in light of the perceived effect on the housing market, and access to public services. And Abbott, who looks back on the government of John Howard (1996-2007) as modern Australia’s golden era, argues for a return of immigration to the 100,000 a year level of that period, compared with current levels of close to 300,000.

Abbott also argues that in light of rising anti-Semitism, Australian migration authorities should put greater emphasis on Australian values to ensure that immigrants want to join “team Australia” and are prepared to forsake anything that might mitigate against that. He believes that Sharia law is consistent with life in a liberal democracy. He staunchly defends the core Anglo-Celtic culture which has made us attractive to millions of people from all around the world.

Abbott speculates on Australia's egalitarianism and “tall poppy syndrome” (by which high-achieving individuals are criticized, resented, ostracized, or "cut down" because their success, talent, or ambition makes others feel insecure or disrupts social equality). It’s simple according to Abbott. When 1500 people of the First Fleet were dumped in an unfamiliar place, on the other side of the world, everyone had to muck in together to survive. This meant that the traditional class, religious and ethnic distinctions of English society were generally left aside. Others also argue that convicts gave us a healthy disrespect for authority and larikinism. Political leadership also played a role as Governor Phillip insisted on everyone being treated equally before the law.

Relations between settlers and Aborigines

Relations between the settlers and the aborigines is a complex subject. The authorities in London gave instructions that the settlers should have cordial relations with the Aborigines, to live in amity with them. And efforts were made in that regard. But according to the "black armband" view of Australian history, there is nothing positive to say on this front.

Abbott recognises that on the frontier of settlement many atrocities were inflicted on the Aboriginal people. But he argues this is not the whole story. It was a story of cooperation as well as conflict, and most explorers relied on Aboriginal guides to get through a country that was new to them, and nearly all of the pastorals relied on Aboriginal stockmen.

Overall, frontier relations were as characterised as much by friendship, cooperation, and adaptation, as conflict. Bennelong, a senior man of the Eora nation from the Port Jackson/Sydney Harbour area was symbolic of the cooperation with the settlement. He served as a key interlocutor, diplomat, and cultural guide between the Eora people and the early British colonists under Governor Arthur Phillip. He was one of the first Aboriginal Australians to travel to Europe, visiting Great Britain in the 1790s and meeting King George III before returning to Australia.

Against that, there was the case of Pemulwuy, the legendary Aboriginal resistance leader and warrior of the Bidjigal clan of the Eora nation. He was one of the most prominent figures of early Indigenous resistance against British colonisation.

The most atrocious incident was the Myall Creek Massacre – the mass murder of at least 28 unarmed Wirrayaraay (Gamilaraay) Aboriginal people – mostly women, children, and old men – by a group of 12 armed colonists and convicts. This incident is most notable in that the guilty settlers were brought to justice. In the first Supreme Court trial, an all-white jury acquitted the men. Following a retrial on charges of murdering a child, seven men were found guilty of murder and publicly hanged at Sydney Gaol. This was the first, but only time in Australian colonial history that European settlers were successfully prosecuted and executed for the mass murder of First Nations people. The Myall Creek Massacre may have been a triumph of justice, but it didn’t stop the massacres. They simply went underground.

The gold rushes

The Australian gold rushes (beginning in 1851) caused a massive demographic and economic boom, increasing Australia's total population nearly fourfold from 430,000 in 1851 to 1.7 million by 1871. In 1851 Victoria separated from NSW to become its own colony. Victoria had the biggest population in Australia, all because of gold.

The gold rushes were one of the most transformational events in Australia’s history, and helped foster significant political change. The Eureka stockade rebellion of 1854 occurred as gold miners from many different countries were revolting against government attempts to regulate and tax gold mining. The Court acquitted the rebels. Abbott regards this a wonderful foundational story for Australian democracy – as miners demanded representation in parliament, the right to vote and buy land.

Political formation of Australia

Prior to the political formation of Australia, the six states of Australia were separate colonies of Britain, with even tariff barriers affecting trade between them. The federation of these colonies into the nation of Australia was unique. There was no war of independence, and no rebellions, unlike in most other countries.

Formal achievement of Australian nationhood was a triumph of politics at its best according to Abbott. A remarkably talented group of leaders managed to turn a noble ideal into practical reality via a decade long process of vigorous public debate, sensible compromise, and ultimately a people’s vote showing that it really was an idea whose time had come.

In sum, Australia is a convict dump made good. It is the most unexpected success story in the modern world. Within seven decades it was one of the most prosperous places on earth, and one of the first self governing democracies in the world.

Taking stock of Abbott’s book

Abbott’s book is a pleasure to read, and is fairly successful in its attempt to offer a balanced view of Australian history. But he is somewhat dismissive of the place of Aborigines in Australian history and society. He says that when all is said and done, Aboriginal people are less than 4% of our population. He laments that the vast majority of contemporary Australian historiography obsesses over indigenous issues. And he insists that we've been overwhelmingly a British society, and our foundational ethos remains Judeo-Christian.

Perhaps the most disappointing aspect of Abbott’s text is the part that deals with the most recent period. Abbott’s own prime ministership (2013-15) was not a success and was the beginning of Liberal Party’s most disappointing decade in government. The Liberal Party has gone from being the natural party of government to being virtually unelectable in the eyes of some. There are many reasons for this, including the changing nature of society, and the Liberal Party’s inability to adapt. Today, Australia stands at a turning point in its modern history, and its continued success is not guaranteed. This sentiment is not reflected in Abbott’s text.
Tags: asia, tony abbott, australia

Social share

Save
Cookies user preferences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Analytics
Tools used to analyze the data to measure the effectiveness of a website and to understand how it works.
Google Analytics
Accept
Decline
Advertisement
If you accept, the ads on the page will be adapted to your preferences.
Google Ad
Accept
Decline